
The COVID-19 pandemic may be slowing down, but life as we know it may never go back to the way it was before. After over two years of adjusting to the “new normal,” the way we live, connect with others, and work has irreversibly changed. And that change is at the heart of the current return-to-office vs. work-from-home debate that has been dominating headlines in the past weeks.
It all started back on March 9, 2022. The Fiscal Incentives Review Board (FIRB) decided to turn down requests from the Philippine Economic Zone Authority (PEZA) to extend remote-work arrangements for the IT-BPM sector, mandating that BPO workers return to the office by April 1, 2022. This decision caused heated debates about both the pros and cons of remote work in the Philippines.
Let’s take a look at both sides of the conversation and see where each party is coming from.
Why Is the Government Mandating RTO?
First, why did the FIRB decide not to extend WFH arrangements for the IT-BPO sector? The short answer is: economic recovery.
It’s no secret that the pandemic had a significant negative effect on the economy. Many businesses had to slow down operations or even close completely. A lot of people lost their jobs, and, as such, had to cut corners and became more selective about when and where to spend their money. Although other countries faced similar problems, the Philippines especially had a really tough time dealing with the effects of this global pandemic.
Throughout this entire two-year crisis, the Philippine IT-BPO sector was able to keep its head above the water because it quickly implemented remote-work arrangements for all employees. BPO companies not only survived, but thrived amid adversity, growing their headcounts by 1.8% while also seeing a 1.4% increase in revenue. This is why BPO workers were seen as “economic frontliners” during the COVID crisis.
Now, the government wants BPO workers, who had become the country’s economic backbone during COVID, to help revitalize the economy. In the words of FIRB chairman Carlos Dominguez III, “The WFH arrangement is only a time-bound temporary measure adopted during the surge of the Covid-19 pandemic. Given the increasing vaccination rate of Filipinos nationwide, we can now undertake safe measures for physical reporting of employees, including those working in the IT-BPM firms.”
Established Companies Back the FIRB’s Decision
In a rare show of solidarity, some of the largest and most established real estate companies in the Philippines, including Ayala Land Inc., Megaworld Corp., Robinsons Land Corp., SM Prime Holdings Inc., and other business groups signed a statement urging workers to return to the office to help stimulate economic growth for the country.
Their shared statement reiterated the FIRB’s insistence that the “path to recovery, we aver, begins with the presence in the business and commercial centers of our country’s workers.” These large companies are making their side of the debate known because the real estate industry is one of the sectors most affected by transition to permanent remote work.
If people with spending power work from home, companies may no longer want to continue buying or leasing office space to accommodate employees. Workers may not feel the need to eat out at SM malls or shop at Ayala stores.
Why Are BPOs Fighting for WFH Arrangements?
The FIRB has been consistent in its stance that BPO companies should return to fully onsite work to help revive the Philippine economy. However, BPO companies, individual workers, and even some politicians have been fighting against the mandate.
Monsour Del Rosario, a senatorial candidate and author of the Telecommuting Act of 2018 in Congress, even called the mandate “cruel and inconsiderate” and urged the FIRB to reconsider. Here are just a few of the reasons why BPOs are against the move to return to office full-time:
Ongoing COVID-19 or Health and Safety Concerns
As of March 2022, more than 65.6 million Filipinos have been vaccinated against COVID-19, with over 11.8 million having received booster shots. The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US-CDC) has also placed the Philippines in “level 2” in their travel advisory, downgraded from “level 3,” following the decreasing number of infections in the country.
The increase in vaccinations and decrease in COVID cases means that the Philippines is making strides in its handling of the virus, paving the way for recovery. However, the pandemic isn’t over yet. Many people are still concerned about COVID exposure, especially those who are living with immunocompromised family members, elderly parents, or young children. Mandating full RTO might mean risking the health and safety of millions of people and possibly causing cases to rise again.
Traffic and Congestion in Metro Manila
The Philippines, Metro Manila in particular, is known worldwide for having terrible traffic conditions. The main reason why the problem persists is because the capital city is among the densest cities in the world, according to the Philippine Statistics Authority’s census.
Before the pandemic, Metro Manila was dubbed the sixth most congested city in Asia, boasting a 53% average congestion level. On average, motorists who commuted in the area lost about 157 hours or equivalent to six days and 13 hours in traffic during rush hours. However, due to the pandemic-related quarantine measures, Metro Manila saw its average congestion level decline from 53% in 2020 to 43% in 2021.
The work-from-home arrangements allowed many BPO workers to avoid the daily struggle of commuting in the overly congested capital city. In fact, many employees even took advantage of the remote-work opportunity and relocated to their provinces, which both decongested Manila and allowed many people to live with their families and cut back on expenses.
State of the Public Transportation System
It’s no secret that Metro Manila has transportation, infrastructure, and urban planning problems, with many of the roads, railways, and public utility vehicles being of poor quality and design. One study found that although there are plenty of public transport options in the country (such as buses, jeepneys, taxis, trains, and tricycles), the everyday citizen still spends an average of 45.5 minutes commuting before reaching their workplace.
Since people were working from home, traffic conditions eased and many got to save so much time and money. Because public transportation systems were not improved during the entire two years where everyone was working from home, BPO workers don’t want to return to the office and face the same traffic problems, which can take a toll on their physical and mental well-being.
Sky-High Gas Prices
The FIRB’s mandate to require employees to start returning to office could not come at a more inconvenient time because gas prices are at an all-time high due to the Ukraine-Russia conflict. The rise in gas prices have made it difficult for car owners, public utility vehicle operators, transport groups, and commuters alike to go about their day-to-day routines.
Is “The Great Resignation” Happening in the Philippines?
Now that we understand both sides and their reasons for wanting to maintain work-from-home arrangements or return to the office, let’s take a look at the effects that this conversation is having. In March 24, the Alliance of Call Center Workers (ACW), a newly organized group promoting the rights of BPO workers, stated that at least four BPO firms have chosen to forgo their tax perks rather than force employees to go back to the office.
BPO employees have also made their voices heard, with a significant number of them considering resigning from their existing jobs if the fully RTO mandate is continued. A representative of the ACW clarified that the mass resignations are not really a protest but more of a personal choice to not be inconvenienced by the sudden return to onsite work. Many BPO workers, after all, had already relocated to the provinces and gave up previous living arrangements in Metro Manila.
So, is this a sign that “The Great Resignation” is beginning to happen in the Philippines?
Well, some researchers suggest that it already began during the pandemic, when the country experienced a 176% increase in voluntary resignations across all industries. However, other experts argue that it won’t and can’t happen because the Philippines is a “labor surplus economy,” meaning that we have a wealth of human capital (thanks to overpopulation) and many live in poverty conditions, so they can’t afford to simply resign from their jobs.
Whether the Philippines will or will not mirror the “Great Resignation” wave that we’ve observed in other countries (particularly the U.S.), one thing is for certain: the way we perceive the nature of work is changing, and the BPO industry is at the forefront of this innovation.
Hybrid Work Is the Future
Two of the Philippines’ biggest employer groups continue to be divided on the WFH vs. RTO debate. The large conglomerates, particularly property and real estate management corporations, are pushing for workers to return to the office, while BPO firms are standing by the benefits and advantages of the remote work arrangements.
According to the ACW, the only real compromise that can be done for now is to implement hybrid work environments. Brien Matthew M. Benitez, a representative of the ACW, stated, “The government should be pro-choice — allow workers the capability to decide whether they want to work from home, or on-site.”
The Philippine Economic Zone Authority (PEZA), which initially wanted workers to fully return to the office, is now issuing a memorandum circular to allow IT-BPO companies to operate with a hybrid work model with 70% onsite and 30% WFH. This change may just be the first step toward greater adoption and acceptance of remote work in the Philippines, as many other developed countries already embraced flexible work arrangements as a means of improving performance, efficiency, convenience, and quality of life for employees.



